Stretching your ringgit: A pre-budget analysis

14 October, 2011

Thirty-year-old marketing executive Johan’s life hasn’t changed since Prime Minister Najib Razak rolled out BN’s “big is better” Budget 2011, best remembered for announcing the 100-storey Warisan Merdeka tower. Like many young working adults, the only house Johan can afford on his current salary is a two-room flat that would entail an hour-long daily commute to his workplace. Johan and his girlfriend are saving to get married, if their parents cannot chip in to pay for the down payment for a modest matrimonial home, the new couple will have to move in with their parents, or rent.

A year has passed since Najib’s polite fiction has failed to uplift the standard of ordinary joes like Johan, despite throwing RM212 billion in a bid to revive the waning economy. The danger signs are now imminent for history to repeat itself as Najib -fresh from his triumphant ISA bait-and-switch stunt- prepares to announce Budget 2012.

 Seri Perdana

Upkeep for the official residences of the prime minister, deputy prime minister and ministers in the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) cost RM3.4 million







We’ve been there, seen that. Clearly, some wizardry is needed to elevate the lives of Johan and millions of ordinary Malaysians. With the 13th General Election looming, this is an ideal moment for Pakatan Rakyat to get radical with its alternative budget.

PR’s alternative budget for 2012, soon to be announced in anticipation of PM Najib Razak’s budget tabling on October 7th -focuses on getting better value for your ringgit.

Malaysia’s bottom 40% income earners take only 15% of total household income.  Whereas the top 20% of households reap nearly half of total household income.





Reckless government overspending

While the many Malaysians like Johan struggle to battle soaring expenses, the government’s notorious overspending and bloated operating expenditure is bleeding the national coffers dry.

According to think tank REFSA, 2011 is the 13th consecutive year of government overspending. The formal term for this ill judgment is the more innocent-sounding “deficit”. In fact, since 1969, there have only been five surplus budgets – the rest recorded deficits.

With the government consistently spending more than its income, the total amount of government overspending for the past 13 years has reached an estimated RM290 billion. This is equivalent to RM10,000 for each Malaysian! However, the impact felt from this generous expenditure has been minimal to the man on the street. Where has all our money gone?

The richest 10% in Malaysia control 38.4% of economic income as compared to the poorest 10% who control only 1.7%. This simply points to the fact the country’s wealth is increasingly concentrated in the rich.

Source: UNDP Human Development Report 2009

Spending… on what?

PR believes it is necessary to reframe the debate from focusing on “spending” to delivering “value” with each ringgit spent. In order to maximize value, PR is committed to cutting down irresponsible spending and reducing wastage.

We should not forget easily the shock the nation suffered when it was discovered that RM1.8million worth of taxpayers’ money was used to pay for a free Facebook page to promote the Ministry of Tourism. Or the Auditor General’s report bringing to light the unjustified expenditure of RM42,320 for a laptop— perhaps the most expensive in the world.

Taking a leaf out of the successful financial management of the four PR state governments, PR’s national alternative budget trains its sights on ineffective spending.

Penang, recently praised in The Economist magazine, has been recording surplus budgets since PR took over in 2008, with cost savings amounting to RM20 million annually. In 2011 the Selangor state government increased its cash reserves to RM1.1 billion, the best ever record for the state. Kedah too registered revenue increase for 3 consecutive years since coming under PR rule.


40% of Malaysians earn less than RM1,500 per month, three quarters of these are bumiputera







Focus on people, not projects

A key thrust of PR’s Alternative Budget 2012 is to empower Malaysians and uplift dignity for all.

For budget expenditure to deliver more value, the alternative budget seeks to focus on projects that benefit people, not cronies. Given the economic slowdown, total spending will be responsibly maintained at RM220 billion. But effective spending will be increased by 20%.

This requires bold and reform-minded policy initiatives. By trimming out white elephant mega projects aimed to enrich fat cats, the direct savings can be channeled where it makes the most difference.

      Proposed budget cuts

  • Prime Minister’s department budget to be slashed 50% from RM15,855 billion to RM7,919 billion.
  • Public Works budget to be reduced by 13%
  • Defence spending to take a slight dip at 6%

Blanket subsidies favor the rich

The existing subsidy policies are deeply flawed. The government spends up to RM25 billion annually on subsidies. That’s equivalent to more than RM2,000 per month for the poorest 1 million Malaysian households. But why are Malaysians still feeling the pinch?

The bulk of this RM25billion is burnt to pay for blanket subsidies, which tend to benefit the rich far more than the poor. For instance, the Porche driver is a bigger beneficiary of petrol subsidies as compared to the Proton Saga driver. Besides fuel, flour, sugar, and other items are universally subsidised for Malaysians of all income levels.

In order to reach the people who need it most, subsidies should be redirected to target the poor. According to PR’s estimate, if the present subsidies are properly targeted and implemented, the poorest 1 million Malaysian households would receive more than RM25,000 per year.

A more efficient welfare system has to be put in place. Besides public provision for healthcare and education, some basic quality of life has to be provided for all citizens. This is especially pressing in this tough economic time. The alternative budget strives to ensure that poverty does not rob the citizens of Malaysia the opportunity to their well-being that they deserve.

Giving your money back to you

  • “Senior Citizen Bonus” RM100 per month for senior citizens above 60 years and earn less than RM1,500 per month
  • “Wages for homemakers” RM200 per month for home-makers whose spouses earn less than RM3,000 per month
  • Minimum wage to be standardised for Peninsular Malaysia based on current common standard of living to be at least RM1,000
  • Top-Ups for hard core poor
  • Personal income tax cut









Other expected areas of concern in the Alternative Budget include open-tender procurement policy to reward innovation and productivity, nurturing civil service excellence and reducing red tape, reviewing lop-sided concessions to improve competitiveness, a proposal for “build, then sell” housing, as well as fiscal decentralization.


Top expected areas of emphasis

  • Education
  • 30% pay rise for teachers
  • RM1.5 billion increase for technical universities
  • Parliament
  • Budget quadrupled to strengthen Parliamentary Democracy
  • Provisions for Select Committee
  • Transport
  • RM1 billion increase to improve public transportation
  • Science, technology and innovation
  • Budget doubled to aggressively pursue Research and Development
  • Information, communication and culture
  • RM1 billion increase to spur internet connectivity



The Alternative Budget 2012 will be a unique policy document showcasing PR solidarity and stands as an expression of confidence by all PR parties towards its common policy platform. Given the diverse economic ideologies held by component parties, coming to agreement on a subject as monumental as the national budget is both a triumph and omen that bodes well for greater PR cooperation.

Moving forward from Buku Jingga and riding at the back of fresh unity forged in the Bersih 2.0 fight for electoral reforms, the newly strengthened coalition flexes its wings and tries on the actual task of governing for size. As polls loom, consolidation is paramount for the coalition. The voters are watching, and they would welcome robust economic reform, something which Najib has so far failed to deliver. –The Rocket

This article was written by on Friday, October 14, 2011 at 11:31 am. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed. Tags:

Comments are closed.

Other News

PAS needs to come clean on its relationship with UMNO

31 July, 2014 0 Comments

By Charles Santiago, Klang MP This is not the first time it has happened. And it certainly won’t be the last. We have, over regular intervals in the past, seen PAS blatantly going against consensus reached by Pakatan Rakyat. Some of the thorny issues remain the formation of an Islamic ... Full Article →

Artist Zunar, relentless fighter against tyranny (Part 2)

23 July, 2014 0 Comments

(…continuation from part 1) Since 2009, we still haven’t seen other cartoonists who shine other than yourself. Why is that so? Ok. With regard to this, I can only provide the space and guidance for cartoonists, I wont be able to turn them into successful cartoonists. That is for themselves ... Full Article →

Thank you, veterans! Because of you, DAP prevails

2 April, 2014 0 Comments

On 2 March, Penang Chief Minister and DAP MP for Bagan Lim Guan Eng hosted a private dinner in honor of the Penang state DAP veterans. There are over 120 veterans in the state who have been party members for over 30 years. Of the number, about 70 turned up ... Full Article →

What’s wrong with the Terengganu crisis?

5 June, 2014 0 Comments

by Political Studies for Change (KPRU) Election fever has become a phenomenon in this equatorial country ever since the March 8 political tsunami, which has changed the political landscape, though the political transformation has not completed yet. To a certain extent, each legislature at federal and state level has put a different complexion on politics. The recent Terengganu political crisis and the storming of the Penang state assembly by UMNO members have to do with legislative politics. Legislative politics is different from election politics. From the parliament to legislature assembly in each state, the most frequent question that has been asked by people is about the attendance of members of elected representative, and as for some other incidents that have happened in legislature they have merely formed a part of their memory as people might find them obscure. Obscurity has become a byword for these pieces of memory due to the fact that people might not have the foggiest about these floating debris of memory. The most unforgettable legislative incident to the people goes to the seizure of power in the Perak state, and despite that, people did not necessarily follow on all the details and issues arising from the incident of seizing power in Perak state. This time - the Terengganu crisis is not only a political crisis, but also a ‘legislative crisis’. The lack of pressure from people in Terengganu lies in the insufficient knowledge about legislative which has saved Najib Razak’s shaky hold on power, as well as the dying Terengganu political and legislative crises from the jaws of death. The incident got serious. Media started to report extensively and non-UMNO members in BN also thought that it was a red flag. However, from the Prime Minister Najib’s statement announcing that the Sultan of Terengganu, Sultan Mizan Zainal Abidin had consented to the resignation of Ahmad Said as well as the appointment of Ahmad Razif Abd Rahman as the new Terengganu Menteri Besar; to the dramatic twist of events where Ahmad Said and and two other UMNO state assemblymen quited the party and then later returned to the party, there appeared an unification in media reporting of the incident from the preparedness to deal with the incidents from different angles. As stability wins over anything else, water leaves behind no trails in its path. From Najib’s statement on 12th May 2014 to the new Menteri Besar Ahman Razif’s taking of oath of office before Sultan Mizan; and to the former Menteri Besar Ahmad Said’s announcement made at his official residence in Kemaman as to his decision to withdraw his resignation from UMNO, the whole process took shorter than two days. Nonetheless, all of the incidents that have occurred in the midst of the Terengganu crisis must not be dismissed out of hand, particularly when comes to the interpretation of matters involving legislative, which calls for some clarification and so that when similar event takes place in future, people in the particular state would no longer stay static in the face of the crisis. This Terengganu crisis, after Ahmad Said and two other UMNO state assemblymen quited the party, left Barisan Nasional with 14 state seats, against Pakatan Rakyat’s 15 in the assembly, giving an equation of 15:14:3, with 3 being the “independent reps”. On the same day, that is, 13th May, the Terengganu state legal advisor Datuk Azhar Abdul Hamid, when contacted by Bernama, has claimed that despite the fact that the number of BN assemblymen had dropped from 17 to 14, the state assembly Speaker was counted as a representative of the ruling state government, thereby giving an equation of 15:15:3. It was Wesak day, which is also a public holiday. After founding director of think tank Political Studies for Change (KPRU), Ooi Heng and his family offered prayers in a Buddhist temple and after he came across Azhar’s misleading statement, Ooi Heng shared his personal view on Facebook, taking the view that the Speaker shall have the casting vote only when the voting comes down to a tie. After talking to a journalist, Ooi Heng is even convinced that the real reason behind Terengganu state legal advisor making misleading statement was to buy some time for UMNO’s political power, so as to resolve the political and legislative crisis. The Federal Constitution has given exposition on legislative power, which includes both parliament and state assembly, and under which the Speaker’s voting right is also covered. The Federal Constitution is basically modeled on the Westminster parliamentary system. Schedule 8, Paragraph 10 (1B) of the Federal Constitution makes it clear that the Speaker of legislative assembly who is not an elected representative has no voting power. Whereas according to the Article 27 (1B) of the Constitution of Terengganu, non-member of the Assembly elected as Speaker has no voting right. Terengganu assembly speaker, Mohd Zubir Embong, is not an elected representative, as he was appointed as assembly speaker on 16th June 2013 after being defeated in the election for Kuala Terengganu parliamentary seat. Hence, the controversy over the question of whether the speaker’s vote can be counted shall not even arise. In fact, not only does the state assembly follow the Westminster legislative custom, but the parliament of Malaysia is also following the system. The Article 57 (1A) of the Federal Constitution clearly provides that any person elected as Speaker of the House of Representatives who is not a member of the House of Representatives has no voting right. Furthermore, according to the Standing Order 45(1), the speaker shall be entitled to give his deciding ballot only when the voting comes down to a tie where ayes are equal to noes. This deciding ballot can be known as the casting vote, or ‘undi pemutus’ in Malay. The aim of this article is to clear doubts on this legislative incident, and as far as the Speaker’s voting right is concerned, no critical comment is intended to be directed at the roles that both government and the opposition have played in this political power crisis. However, I am of the opinion that despite the misleading statement by the state legal advisor, government and opposition elites should still be held responsible politically for this legislative incident. It is indeed bizarre that both government and opposition have no idea about the legislative procedures in the Terengganu state assembly when most of the assembly members are from UMNO and PAS. In the two days within which the 3 UMNO state assemblymen became ‘independent reps’ (Less than 48 hours), Terengganu state assembly has actually been beset with crisis. While there was likely UMNO fall down in Terengganu, UMNO has nonetheless got themselves some time to stabilise their shaky hold on power. Apart from UMNO taking the lead in this incident, the fact that PAS was being indifferent to the misleading statement will go down in the history of legislative politics. History is bound to repeat when political elite’s political action has not been properly examined. -The Rocket * The views expressed in this article are the personal opinion of the columnist ... Full Article →