Merdeka at 55

30 July, 2012

by T.K Tan

As Peninsular Malaysia ushers in its 55th year of existence, for many of us, there is not much to celebrate about. Many Malaysians are discontented with the order of things in the federation. Can we rise above the dismal state of affairs?

Fractured State of Union

After 55 years, we are no closer to achieving the Bangsa Malaysia (Malaysian race) ideal. Indeed latent distrust towards each other seems to be the order of the day, no thanks to the divide and rule tactics of the longest elected party in the world, UMNO.

In a series of opinion polls conducted by Merdeka Centre from 2006 to 2011, the results show a deteriorating trend of national unity.  In 2006, 45 percent of those surveyed considered themselves Malaysian first. In 2011, a similar poll registered only 39 percent affirmative response.

Deputy Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin’s famous diatribe calling himself a ‘Malay first, Malaysian second’ is unfortunately a shared view for many of us. In the 2006 poll, more than half the Malay respondents think of themselves as Malays first.

The 2006 survey asked the respondents why are they proud of being a Malaysian? 47 percent answered that it was only due to the peace and stability in this country. Are we merely co-existing with each other in this land? Is Bangsa Malaysia a pipe dream for us?

Beware the Watchmen

When the Alliance parties of UMNO, MCA and MIC negotiated independence for Malaya in 1956, they were entrusted to bring a fair deal for Malayans.

Unlike the unsubstantiated social contract mentioned by Tun Dr Mahathir that threatens those who question the sanctity of Malay ‘rights’, the understanding was for everyone to be able to benefit equally from this entity known as Federation of Malaya.

However, UMNO-BN’s five decades of mismanagement has returned a dismal record. After 55 years, Indians are the second poorest community in Malaysia. They form 60 percent of the squatter urban squatters and 41 percent of the beggars (The Economist 22 February 2003).

According to researcher Jayanath Appudurai, 32 percent of Indian households are living below poverty level, the highest proportion in Peninsular Malaysia.

For those who are mobile and educated, overseas destinations and jobs are the natural course of choice. According to the World Bank Report “Malaysia Economic Monitor: Brain Drain” (MEMBD), more than 1 million Malaysians have left the country. 88 percent are Chinese.

As for the Malays, UMNO’s entrusted stead, the record is not much better. Despite being blessed with oil and gas resources, Kelantan and Terengganu, the overwhelming Malay-majority states, are ranked third and fourth in the nation’s poverty rates.

The much maligned New Economic Policy (NEP) which was launched to address the wealth disparity amongst the races after the May 13 racial riots has been abused beyond recognition.

The Malay community’s Gini coefficient (measure of income distribution disparity) is consistently higher than the Chinese and Indians despite them receiving lower distribution of the NEP’s largesse in aggregate. In short, UMNO has failed everyone miserably.

A Monster Reared

At the core of the malaise besetting the nation is UMNO’s greed and wicked design for maintaining power. Its history of political dominance has been manifest since 1957.

From 1960 onwards, the Alliance with its legislative dominance amended the constitution numerous times in order to control the appointment of the Election Commission (EC) members.

It gave the incumbent government control over the EC and to gerrymander the electorate seats expansively that allowed UMNO and the Alliance to win general elections handily. (1)

When any states still showed political defiance, UMNO was not above interfering unconstitutionally in state governments. Malaya witnessed its first fall of an elected opposition state government in Terengganu after some PAS ADUNs defected to UMNO after inducements were dangled for them.

In Kelantan in 1978, an emergency situation was declared over the state after a crisis was manufactured by UMNO-linked demonstrators. UMNO subsequently won the state elections over a weakened PAS. (2)

But the most brutal crisis ever concocted by UMNO was the May 13 racial riots that saw unaccounted number of deaths. To this day no independent commission of inquiry to investigate the cause or the happenings of the bloody incident has ever been engaged by the UMNO government.

The government’s White Paper attached the blame mostly on DAP and unofficially, the Chinese. UMNO has since then constantly used the racial riots as a foil to scaremonger the Malays into believing they would lose power if UMNO loses the elections.

Engineering A Mindset

Since the 1970s, the UMNO government has embarked on indoctrinating the Malay supremacy mindset. According to studies made by the Centre of Malaysian Chinese Studies (CMCS) and Nanyang University Alumni Association of Malaya (NYUAA, Malaya), school history textbook content began to heavily report Malay accounts at the expense of other races. Even museums’ contents mostly reflected Malay perspective.

Civil servants composition too began to be dominated overwhelmingly by one race. According to a report by Ipoh Timor MP Lim Kit Siang, in the 1970s Malays form around 60 percent of the civil service. In 2010 the figure is 78 percent.

Whenever opposition parties question the implementation of the NEP, UMNO invariably uses it as an excuse that it is a questioning of Malay rights. This poisoned mindset has bred mistrust particularly amongst the Malays toward others.

A 2010 Merdeka Centre survey poll shows that 72 percent of the Malays continued to believe the necessity of NEP to help the Malays in spite of its many failures.

With political dominance came hubris and corruption. While other countries such as Indonesia and the Philippines have been improving their corruption rankings, Malaysia’s ranking has been falling since 1995, from sixth position to 11th position.

Restoring A Promise

Former Prime Minister Tunku Abdul Rahman once said his aim was to build a prosperous and happy Malayan society. Unfortunately for us, UMNO’s dismal record in ruling the nation shows why it will never happen.

UMNO has shamelessly continued to use the May 13 riots to scaremonger the people to vote it into power in every GE. In addition it intentionally keeps the people poor in order to win their votes through vote buying in GE.

It is no secret why Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak has won his biggest approval from the poorest segment of the society in many of the opinion polls conducted, courtesy of his populist measures. (Free Malaysia Today, 1 June 2012).

Can we change the course of events? The March 2008 general election result was a fortuitous event for Malaysians. The long forgotten principles of transparent, honest and accountable governance are making its way back in the Pakatan Rakyat-run states of Penang, Selangor, Kedah and Kelantan.

However that providential bounty is under risk. Perak PR government lasted just under 11 months before an unconstitutional and ugly power coup felled it.

An electoral fraud is now being engineered in Selangor. Reports of a large number of unaccounted voter registrations are surfacing there, triggering possibility of the incumbent PR government being voted out with phantom voters.

The wall that UMNO constructed by dividing the people await our tearing it down. It begins when we start disbelieving lies peddled to perpetuate it for the benefit of the select. Will Malaysians take heed? – The Rocket

1) Electoral Politics in Malaysia : ‘Managing’ Elections in A Plural Society
2) Islam Embedded: The Historical Development of PAS, Farish A. Noor

This article was written by on Monday, July 30, 2012 at 5:34 pm. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

1 Comment

  • Kakoli Mukherjee

    Start considering the local born Chinese and Indian as sons of the soil as well. Its sad that the dismal view of my future prompted my parents to scrunch, save and sacrifice to send both my sister and myself overseas where we have a chance of a free future where equality, freedom of speech and expression and the general pursuit of hapiness can be achieved.
    Malaysia of my childhood and Malaysia of today is completely divergent. Corrupt politicians with self-serving agendas and fanatical religious overtones have drowned out the heart and soul of this country.
    I pray for the moment when Malaysia goes back to the day that Tunku Abdul Rahman, Tun VT Sambanthan and Tun Dato Cheng-Lock Tan heralded a free and equal future for Malaysia.

Leave a Reply

Other News

The story behind parliamentary written replies

23 July, 2014 0 Comments

By Lu Wei Hoong Early last month, PKR’s Bagan Serai MP N Surendran slammed the institution of Parliament as “a waste of money”, because recent events have shown that it merely acts as a “rubber stamp” for the government of the day. To members of the media who cover the ... Full Article →

Artist Zunar, relentless fighter against tyranny (Part 2)

23 July, 2014 0 Comments

(…continuation from part 1) Since 2009, we still haven’t seen other cartoonists who shine other than yourself. Why is that so? Ok. With regard to this, I can only provide the space and guidance for cartoonists, I wont be able to turn them into successful cartoonists. That is for themselves ... Full Article →

Thank you, veterans! Because of you, DAP prevails

2 April, 2014 0 Comments

On 2 March, Penang Chief Minister and DAP MP for Bagan Lim Guan Eng hosted a private dinner in honor of the Penang state DAP veterans. There are over 120 veterans in the state who have been party members for over 30 years. Of the number, about 70 turned up ... Full Article →

What’s wrong with the Terengganu crisis?

5 June, 2014 0 Comments

by Political Studies for Change (KPRU) Election fever has become a phenomenon in this equatorial country ever since the March 8 political tsunami, which has changed the political landscape, though the political transformation has not completed yet. To a certain extent, each legislature at federal and state level has put a different complexion on politics. The recent Terengganu political crisis and the storming of the Penang state assembly by UMNO members have to do with legislative politics. Legislative politics is different from election politics. From the parliament to legislature assembly in each state, the most frequent question that has been asked by people is about the attendance of members of elected representative, and as for some other incidents that have happened in legislature they have merely formed a part of their memory as people might find them obscure. Obscurity has become a byword for these pieces of memory due to the fact that people might not have the foggiest about these floating debris of memory. The most unforgettable legislative incident to the people goes to the seizure of power in the Perak state, and despite that, people did not necessarily follow on all the details and issues arising from the incident of seizing power in Perak state. This time - the Terengganu crisis is not only a political crisis, but also a ‘legislative crisis’. The lack of pressure from people in Terengganu lies in the insufficient knowledge about legislative which has saved Najib Razak’s shaky hold on power, as well as the dying Terengganu political and legislative crises from the jaws of death. The incident got serious. Media started to report extensively and non-UMNO members in BN also thought that it was a red flag. However, from the Prime Minister Najib’s statement announcing that the Sultan of Terengganu, Sultan Mizan Zainal Abidin had consented to the resignation of Ahmad Said as well as the appointment of Ahmad Razif Abd Rahman as the new Terengganu Menteri Besar; to the dramatic twist of events where Ahmad Said and and two other UMNO state assemblymen quited the party and then later returned to the party, there appeared an unification in media reporting of the incident from the preparedness to deal with the incidents from different angles. As stability wins over anything else, water leaves behind no trails in its path. From Najib’s statement on 12th May 2014 to the new Menteri Besar Ahman Razif’s taking of oath of office before Sultan Mizan; and to the former Menteri Besar Ahmad Said’s announcement made at his official residence in Kemaman as to his decision to withdraw his resignation from UMNO, the whole process took shorter than two days. Nonetheless, all of the incidents that have occurred in the midst of the Terengganu crisis must not be dismissed out of hand, particularly when comes to the interpretation of matters involving legislative, which calls for some clarification and so that when similar event takes place in future, people in the particular state would no longer stay static in the face of the crisis. This Terengganu crisis, after Ahmad Said and two other UMNO state assemblymen quited the party, left Barisan Nasional with 14 state seats, against Pakatan Rakyat’s 15 in the assembly, giving an equation of 15:14:3, with 3 being the “independent reps”. On the same day, that is, 13th May, the Terengganu state legal advisor Datuk Azhar Abdul Hamid, when contacted by Bernama, has claimed that despite the fact that the number of BN assemblymen had dropped from 17 to 14, the state assembly Speaker was counted as a representative of the ruling state government, thereby giving an equation of 15:15:3. It was Wesak day, which is also a public holiday. After founding director of think tank Political Studies for Change (KPRU), Ooi Heng and his family offered prayers in a Buddhist temple and after he came across Azhar’s misleading statement, Ooi Heng shared his personal view on Facebook, taking the view that the Speaker shall have the casting vote only when the voting comes down to a tie. After talking to a journalist, Ooi Heng is even convinced that the real reason behind Terengganu state legal advisor making misleading statement was to buy some time for UMNO’s political power, so as to resolve the political and legislative crisis. The Federal Constitution has given exposition on legislative power, which includes both parliament and state assembly, and under which the Speaker’s voting right is also covered. The Federal Constitution is basically modeled on the Westminster parliamentary system. Schedule 8, Paragraph 10 (1B) of the Federal Constitution makes it clear that the Speaker of legislative assembly who is not an elected representative has no voting power. Whereas according to the Article 27 (1B) of the Constitution of Terengganu, non-member of the Assembly elected as Speaker has no voting right. Terengganu assembly speaker, Mohd Zubir Embong, is not an elected representative, as he was appointed as assembly speaker on 16th June 2013 after being defeated in the election for Kuala Terengganu parliamentary seat. Hence, the controversy over the question of whether the speaker’s vote can be counted shall not even arise. In fact, not only does the state assembly follow the Westminster legislative custom, but the parliament of Malaysia is also following the system. The Article 57 (1A) of the Federal Constitution clearly provides that any person elected as Speaker of the House of Representatives who is not a member of the House of Representatives has no voting right. Furthermore, according to the Standing Order 45(1), the speaker shall be entitled to give his deciding ballot only when the voting comes down to a tie where ayes are equal to noes. This deciding ballot can be known as the casting vote, or ‘undi pemutus’ in Malay. The aim of this article is to clear doubts on this legislative incident, and as far as the Speaker’s voting right is concerned, no critical comment is intended to be directed at the roles that both government and the opposition have played in this political power crisis. However, I am of the opinion that despite the misleading statement by the state legal advisor, government and opposition elites should still be held responsible politically for this legislative incident. It is indeed bizarre that both government and opposition have no idea about the legislative procedures in the Terengganu state assembly when most of the assembly members are from UMNO and PAS. In the two days within which the 3 UMNO state assemblymen became ‘independent reps’ (Less than 48 hours), Terengganu state assembly has actually been beset with crisis. While there was likely UMNO fall down in Terengganu, UMNO has nonetheless got themselves some time to stabilise their shaky hold on power. Apart from UMNO taking the lead in this incident, the fact that PAS was being indifferent to the misleading statement will go down in the history of legislative politics. History is bound to repeat when political elite’s political action has not been properly examined. -The Rocket * The views expressed in this article are the personal opinion of the columnist ... Full Article →